Introduction: Why Notes from Underground Still Matters
Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Notes from Underground (1864) is one of the most influential and provocative novellas in modern literature. Often cited as the first existentialist novel, it laid the foundation for a new way of understanding human psychology, free will, and the absurdity of modern life.
In this philosophical monologue, Dostoevsky dismantles the optimistic belief in reason and progress, confronting readers with the raw, uncomfortable truths of human nature. This article will explore the themes, characters, and enduring relevance of Notes from Underground, with a focus on its place in literature and philosophy.
Overview: What Is Notes from Underground About?
Divided into two parts, Notes from Underground presents the musings and memories of a bitter, isolated man living in St. Petersburg. He is unnamed but famously referred to as the “Underground Man”—a retired civil servant who has turned away from society and chosen solitude.
-
Part I – “Underground”: A philosophical rant where the narrator attacks rationalism, utopianism, and the idea that humans always act in their self-interest.
-
Part II – “Apropos of the Wet Snow”: A more narrative-driven section, where the Underground Man recalls humiliating events from his younger life that illustrate the theories he rants about in Part I.
Main Themes in Notes from Underground
1. The Illusion of Rationality
Dostoevsky was reacting to the rise of Enlightenment rationalism and utilitarianism. Philosophers like Chernyshevsky argued that human behavior could be optimized through reason. Dostoevsky, through the Underground Man, argues the opposite: humans are not logical machines. They often act irrationally—sometimes just to prove they can.
“Man only likes to count his troubles; he doesn’t calculate his happiness.”
2. Free Will and Self-Destruction
A central argument of the novella is that free will is sacred—even if it leads to suffering. The Underground Man believes that being able to choose irrationally is what makes us human. If we were bound by logic alone, we’d be no better than programmed machines.Dostoevsky challenges the 19th-century belief that human behavior can be predicted and improved through reason and science. The Underground Man argues that such ideologies ignore the irrational aspects of human nature, asserting that individuals may act against their best interests simply to assert their free will.
3. Alienation and Isolation
The Underground Man lives in complete isolation. His self-hatred and social anxiety drive him away from others, but he also blames society for being shallow and hypocritical. This alienation is both personal and symbolic, representing the condition of modern man.
4. Consciousness as a Curse
His overthinking and philosophical awareness paralyze him. The more he thinks, the less he acts. This existential burden—of knowing too much, but doing nothing—is a theme that would later appear in the works of Sartre, Kafka, and Camus.
Character Study: The Underground Man
The Underground Man is not a hero. He is bitter, self-loathing, contradictory, and unreliable—but deeply intelligent. His self-awareness is both his weapon and his wound. He mocks societal values yet desperately wants to be accepted. He is deeply alone yet resents others for it.
This internal conflict makes him one of literature’s first true anti-heroes.
Literary Significance and Influence
Notes from Underground is a precursor to existentialist philosophy and modern psychological fiction. Dostoevsky’s exploration of free will, rebellion against reason, and the inner torment of man influenced writers like:
-
Jean-Paul Sartre (Nausea)
-
Franz Kafka (The Metamorphosis)
-
Albert Camus (The Myth of Sisyphus)
-
Virginia Woolf and James Joyce (stream-of-consciousness style)
This novella marked a radical break from traditional realism, embracing interior monologue, contradictory narration, and philosophical introspection.
Modern Relevance: Why Read Notes from Underground Today?
In an age of algorithms, hyper-rationalism, and social conformity, Dostoevsky’s message hits harder than ever. The Underground Man speaks for anyone who’s ever felt out of place, trapped by their own thoughts, or disillusioned with modern life.
Whether you’re a literature lover, a student of philosophy, or someone seeking meaning in chaos, Notes from Underground challenges you to face your own contradictions—and accept them.
Conclusion: A Window into the Dark Side of the Human Soul
Notes from Underground is not an easy read. It’s dark, uncomfortable, and intellectually challenging—but that’s what makes it powerful. Dostoevsky forces us to confront the irrational, ugly, and deeply human parts of ourselves that society often asks us to ignore.
Through the voice of the Underground Man, we’re reminded that the search for meaning is never clean—and perhaps that’s the point.
FAQs About Notes from Underground
Q: Is Notes from Underground hard to read?
Yes, due to its philosophical depth and unreliable narrator, it requires focus—but it’s richly rewarding.
Q: What is the main message of the book?
That humans are irrational beings who value freedom—even the freedom to make bad choices—over pure logic or comfort.
Q: Is this book connected to existentialism?
Absolutely. It’s considered one of the earliest works of existentialist literature.
